ACP Spring 2024 Conference
March 7–9, La Jolla, Calif.
Table of Contents
Administrative/Leadership: For MEs + editors
The power of workplace integrity ………………………………………………… March 7
Newsroom management for students and advisers ……………………………….. March 8
How to be a strong newsroom leader ……………………………………………... March 8
Excellence and mental health can coexist: Discussion for editors ………………... March 8
Make your policy manual a living document ……………………………………... March 9
DEI tools for your newsroom ……………………………………………………... March 9
Daily-wide: Professional skills
Building trust with your audience ………………………………………………… March 7
The future of media and technology………………………………………………. March 7
Nine skills you need to land your first newsroom job ……………………………. March 7
An introduction to the Deliberative Journalism Project …………………………... March 8
Redefining community in the practice of journalism ……………………………... March 8
Daily-wide: Editorial skills
Student press freedom 101 ………………………………………………………… March 7
Copyright 101 ……………………………………………………………………... March 7
Words matter: Making your content more inclusive ………………………………. March 7
Freedom of Information law ……………………………………………………….. March 7
Covering sexual assault, legally …………………………………………………… March 7
Reporting on trans issues …………………………………………………………... March 7
Covering protests …………………………………………………………………... March 8
Writing about trauma in nonfiction ………………………………………………… March 9
Audience Engagement
Audience engagement ……………………………………………………………… March 7
Audience engagement 101 …………………………………………………………. March 8
How to brand across multiple platforms …………………………………………… March 9
Copy
Words matter: Making your content more inclusive ………………………………. March 7
Reporting on trans issues …………………………………………………………... March 7
Design
Design: Walk the walk ……………………………………………………………... March 7
Inclusive design: If it’s not accessible it’s not inclusive …………………………… March 7
Traditional art in the digital age …………………………………………………… March 8
Good designers copy. Great designers steal ……………………………………….. March 8
Digital Sections
Inclusive design: If it’s not accessible it’s not inclusive …………………………… March 7
News
Correct me if I’m wrong ………………………………………………………….. March 7
Covering climate, starting from your own campus ………………………………. March 7
Localizing the presidential election ………………………………………………. March 8
Getting pushback from administration? Push back ………………………………. March 8
Breaking news coverage and tight deadlines …………………………………….. March 9
Covering the capitol from your campus …………………………….……………. March 9
Covering campus death ………………………………………………………….. March 9
Photo
Covering protests …………………………………………………………………... March 8
Inclusive design: If it’s not accessible it’s not inclusive …………………………… March 7
Podcast
Podcasting for student media ………………………………………………………. March 8
Thursday, March 7
Building Trust With Your Audience
Mar 7, 2024 12:00 PM PST
Speaker: Lynn Walsh, Trusting News (lynn@trustingnews.org)
- Journalists can’t persuade everyone to trust them → not their job
- Building trust is two-sided
- From consumers: news and media literacy
- From journalists: fact-checking, being clear about mission and ethics
- Includes both transparency and engagement
- Transparency
- Tell people about your ethics/goal/mission
- EG: San Diego Union-Tribune uses ethics checklist to ensure they meet X criteria for each article; published on their site
- How do you get people to look at this information?
- Remember your audience; leave the journalism jargon behind, make sure it’s accessible to readers in its language and content
- Behind your reporting:
- Why did we report this story?
- Explain your decision-making process, and draw attention to it
- EG: If you use AP to call local/national political races, link to the AP’s explainer and say you trust its methods
- EG: In 2020, Milwaukee Journal Sentinel published an explainer on their Kenosha coverage, incl. why they used the term “protest” vs. “riot”
- Engagement
- Understand your audience, who you’re reaching and who you’re not reaching
- What niche do you reach in your community?
- How are you different from your community?
- Diversity: Newsrooms are not reflective of the communities they cover — this needs to change
- Understand what you might be missing in your coverage?
- News avoidance is at an all-time high, and talking to the community helps us understand how we can make our coverage better
- Have conversations with community members
- Trusting News’ Community Interview Guide
- Listen to people in the community and understand where their mistrust in journalism is rooted
- Findings from other conversations: community members want diversity in newsrooms, solution-oriented articles instead of just issue coverage
- Dealing with turnover in newsrooms, and decisions made before your tenure
- Get policies in writing and publish them!
- Corrections policy
- Being intentional about language used in these policies
- EG: “things we will consider” vs. “we will always do this”
- Admitting that past mistakes were wrong, and explaining how you are working to correct them or how things have changed since
- Be willing to hold yourself accountable for mistakes
Design: Walk the Walk
Mar 7, 2024 12:00 PM PST
Speaker: Jon Wile, American City Business Schools
- Fewer photos, run one big photo
- Phones are for lots of photos, print is for one big
- Crios create a more engaging layout
- Building relationships between designers and photographers
- They do a lot of photo editing
- Facilitating working relationships to ensure crops are approved, see if they have better photos for the spread, regardless of what they like
- How photographers see view or would tell this story
- Marriage of words and visual
- Their designers edit headlines to say the same thing as the illustration
- Repetition
- Go back and look at old work
- Look at what you’ve changed, what you haven't, what you’re good at, what you’re not – taking time with people you feel can develop talent
- Focus on being a journalist
- What do readers need and want, not just what is decorative
- Join Society for News Design (he’s president)
- Student News Design Competition has opened
The Future of Media and Technology
Mar 7, 2024 12:00 PM PST
Speaker: Neil Mandt, Movie and TV producer
- Beginning of the fourth industrial revolution is upon us
- Artificial intelligence has been used for many years
- Sora AI: made by Open AI, these videos were made one week ago, these videos are remarkable and look real
- In the future, will people be able to feed AI a written prompt and make a movie?
- Studies of content creation should be broad
- Blockchain: decentralized services that are doing basic things, chain between servers is broken once something goes wrong (like hacking), this allows us to record ownership of things of value that no one can see, tells us who owns what
- What is the Metaverse?
- The 3D Internet
- Augmented reality and virtual reality that can lead into virtual worlds
- What is the difference between augmented reality and virtual reality?
- Both change the way we use screens
- Virtual reality uses a headset with built in screen that creates an environment, uses head tracking
- Augmented reality does not transport someone to a virtual world but uses images and uses them as a layer over the world around them
- Neil believes augmented reality will be bigger than the printing press, the electric light, and the internet combined because it will change education, communication, commerce, and shrink the world
- He spoke about Apple Vision Pros, saying that people should buy them if they want to be a pro
- Augmented Reality (AR) glasses are also here - an enterprise product
- Used to break down language barriers and help those who cannot hear well
- Mojo Vision’s
- No one will be using a smartphone in 2028, we are going to wear glasses or contacts
- These things are app based!
- Work from home will look like something we cannot image soon
- When AR goes mainstream, what will happen?
- New influencers will always be in our vision, these things can be sold through Instagram or Meta
- Get paid to have a website in your vision always, you don’t even need to click on it
- PEOPLE START TO AUGMENT THEMSELVES
- Real world consequences and real world opportunities
- LiDAR: a tool that can scan your environment and add things, can place things back in an environment - news stories will be at the point of the story and will be discoverable on an app through AR, we can RELIVE these stories (some of which are horrific)
- Can use iPhone 13 Pro!
- BMW robots and Elon Musk is making robots - these are advanced conversational AI robots
- Neurolink: Elon Musk put chips in monkey’s brains… applications for humans. We can literally be immortal in this reality. We can download our brain onto a hard drive and live forever as a robot
- Really crazy ideas
- Try to conceive of these possibilities so we’re not “left behind”, according to Neil
- Can you own inspiration?
- Do we owe money to people who inspire us?
- AI-generated content is new, we can put Taylor Swift’s songs and create something new
- Democratization of long form content creation
- Can use an AR kit on iPhone right now!
- Look at Adobe Aero
- 3D media will be more powerful in storytelling
- Can be used in a collegiate
- Some policy is irrelevant in the Metaverse
- Not much psychology involved in this way
Nine Skills You Need to Land Your First Newsroom Job
Mar 7, 2024 1:00 PM PST
Speaker: Rick Green, Lexington Herald
- (1) Power of observation and always being aware of/ready for breaking news
- (2) Rapid synthesis and analysis
- (3) Integrity
- Advocacy journalism → serves a specific cause
- Can be positive, but can also create echochambers (think Tucker Carlson, Rachel Maddow, etc. → Sam’s addition: Jake Tapper yuck)
- How can we reconcile this role with broad mistrust of journalists?
- Why have journalists lost credibility?
- Highest media credibility was in the 1970s
- Watergate! Woohoo journalism slay
- Walter Cronkite and Vietnam
- Social media, politicization/polarization of media
- More options for media consumption over time has allowed people to choose what they consume
- Advocacy journalism, what is it?
- Journalism done for a cause
- Likely one-sided
- These people won’t be hired in a newsroom
- (4) Fairness and impartiality
- (5) Intellectual curiosity
- (6) Passion → love what you do!
- Resiliency because journalism will break you !
- (7) Master the basics
- (8) Humility
- Can help get you in the door and build credibility, integrity
- (9) Gratitude
- Remember the people who teach and mentor you!
- Develop relationships, share information, get to know each other
Audience Engagement
Mar 7, 2024 1:00 PM PST
Speaker: Bella Ross, social media journalists, formally San Diego Union-Tribune, former EiC of The Daily Aztec, @bellamayaross
- What is AE?
- Take a proactive approach to building relationships
- Pushes against ways news organizations have historically ostracized audience
- Audience Listening
- Not just looking at analytics, emails, comments
- Can include:
- Community advisory boards
- Meetings w community groups (more informally about how to best meet community needs)
- EG: “brews and news” – at SD Union Tribune people go to brewery to talk to people about the news, decisions, get to know journalists
- Listening events
- Digital polling and outreach used as entry to deeper convos
- Social Media
- Collaborate with local creators
- Engage with comments
- They encourage clarifying/answering questions in the comments (?)
- Community events
- Learn what people want to know about your journalism (what to ask community leaders, politicians, etc. in interviews)
- Community Mapping Activity – who relies on your coverage
The Power of Workplace Integrity
Mar 7, 2024 1:00 PM PST
Speaker: Tamara Zellars Buck, Southeast Missouri University
- Workplace integrity: environments free of harassment, discrimination, and incivility, and filled with opportunity, especially for those who have traditionally been denied it.
- Critical thinking in newsroom workplaces
- Critical thinking: Realizing that there is always room to improve your reasoning abilities, and you will inevitably at times fall pretty to mistakes in reasoning, rationality, biases, prejudice, social rules/taboos, etc.
- “If both sides are complaining about our story, we must be doing something right”
- Problems:
- Reducing issues to “both sides” is oversimplifying
- Use of the term “complaining” delegitimizes feedback in itself, deems them as being wrong, does not encourage use of feedback
- Encourages false equivalency — “both sides” do not always have the same amount and quality of information and reputability, don’t need to give equal weight to all perspectives
- Bases objectivity based off of people not liking your content; maybe people don’t like your content because it’s bad
- “They’re both adults; it’s not our issue”
- Personal bleeds into the workplace (how people interact, how they do their work, etc.)
- “Only”
- Takes away from/downplays the gravity of situations
- Once can be bad enough
- How do we challenge wrongs in the workplace?
- Courageous conversations: values-driven communication in the face of present or potential conflict
- Conflict: Expressed struggle between 2+ interdependent parties who perceive incompatible goals, scarce resources, and interference from others in achieving their goals
- Balancing act between reaching our goals and preserving relationships
- Understand what your goal is as a newsroom and why it matters
- Sometimes this is going to be super biased one way: e.g. if someone plagiarizes, you fire them and put goals > relationships
- Proactive vs. reactive conversations
- Proactive
- Enable you to bring up a challenge or concern ahead of time ⇒ be solutions-oriented
- Declare a position on an issue and create opportunities to advise on it
- Reactive
- Reply to words/respond to actions directed at you
- Be an “active bystander”; speak up for others
- Report wrongdoing that you might have not witnessed or experienced
- Tips
- Be clear about your goal: what outcome do you want from the conversation
- Calibrate your conversations to be in line with the desired meeting goal/outcome
- Understand your own conflict style and prepare ahead of time as much as possible
- Avoid hyperbolic language
- Call out behaviors and things that must change
- Document and report everything, formalizing conversations
Correct Me if I’m Wrong
Mar 7, 2024 2:00 PM PST
Speaker: Kirstie Hettinga, California Lutheran University, faculty adviser for their paper and former Fresno State EiC (khetting@callutheran.edu)
- Speaker conducted a review of more than 400 college newspapers
- Just over half had any locatable correction on their website
- Almost 40% were over a year old
- Only 6% had corrected something on their most recent issue
- More corrections ≠ more mistakes!
- Means more transparency :)
- Most common errors → names, numbers, and over-emphasis
- Over-emphasis: making something seem like more of a big deal than it really is, and gets more at tone and formatting rather than a simple correction
- In comparison, a study of the NYT, WaPo, LA Times, and WSJ found the most common errors were personal references, numbers, and misquotes (often misattribution)
- Aspects of quotes that need to be checked: person it came from, context it was said in, accuracy of quote content
- Corrections policies are a crucial aspect of transparency
- Evidence is not overwhelming, but making corrections has a non-negative impact on perceptions of credibility and transparency
- In a review of 15 student newspaper handbooks:
- All talk about accuracy (to varying degrees), but one-third did not have any kind of corrections policy
- Correction standards are often influenced by individual editors
- Much more likely to see corrections when editors set them as a priority, so practices lack consistency due to high turnover
- Advice for dealing with takedown requests:
- Remind them that newspaper content has always lived in perpetuity, even pre-digital times
- Regardless of print vs. digital format, writers are always expected to be accountable for what they write
- What should be corrected?
- Don’t be prescriptive of what should or shouldn’t be corrected → instead, give examples of things that might be corrected
- Try to be open-ended in your policy
- “Scrubbing” (fixing typos) is not the same thing as a correction
- Anything that changes facts or meaning must be documented
- Best practices for writing corrections
- Research tells us it is bad to repeat the mistake!
- EG: Rather than “A previous version of this article spelled John Smyth’s name as John Smith” do “A previous version of this article misspelled John Smyth’s name”
- Don’t cast blame
- When readers see corrections that attribute the mistake, they think the correction is less important
- EG: Avoid things like “Due to an editing error, John Smyth’s name was misspelled.”
- Corrections matter <3
- A small thing you can do to show your readers you are committed to getting things right
Student Press Freedom 101
Mar 7, 2024 2:00 PM PST
Speaker:
- Overall: This feels far more relevant for papers who are affiliated with the university (and would thus be in danger of having funding pulled, admin making editorial decisions)
- Tinker v Des Moines
- 1967-2005 - hands-off public media model
- Forms of censorship prohibited:
- Indirect:
- Cutting off funding
- Firing editor or staff
- Stacking a publication board
- Removing or disciplining advisor
- Investigations
- Media relations or PR gag orders
- In order to make a first amendment claim, you have to have enough evidence that action was taken for content-related reasons
- Important to hold onto information and knowledge about problem people/areas because of frequent turnover
- If you hear something suspicious, pass the information along
- There are certain states (Illinois) where public university presidents can limit student journalism (uh oh!!)
- Hosty v. Carter
- → new voices laws
- Resources! Student Press Law Center
- Hotline: https://splc.org/legalhelp/
Covering Climate, Starting From Your Own Campus
Mar 7, 2024 2:00 PM PST
Speaker: Phillip Salata, iNewSource, a local nonprofit newsroom with investigative government accountability, and MacKenzie Elmer, Voice of San Diego
- Environmental reporting is a broad way to talk about culture and infrastructure and so much more - opportunity to cover lots of different things!
- Do a lot of investigative reporting and entertainment reporting even at iNews Source
- More conversational writing at their news organization
- Energy is getting expensive!
- Conflict is a new pressure to understand how policies can change!
- Alternative sources of energy - batteries and salt use (don’t always need to Lithium)
- Don’t always try to sound smart, especially when speaking with experts who use a lot of jargon
- Importance of local journalism, those stories stay, climate reporting starts somewhere
- Local issues symbolize so many threats
- More important to localize environmental issues - reaching voters in local communities to save ourselves
- Hitting the hearts and minds of those around us
- How do you get access to expert sources or underrepresented communities?
- Show up, go physically to meetings
- Know the customs that are important to different communities
- Build trust within communities
- Sources are people, keep boundaries to some extent but understand their humanity
- There should be no surprises in publication - if you are going to make someone mad, they should know that in advance (but still follow basic journalism ethics)
- How to balance reporting considering climate anxiety and the harshness of climate change?
- Focus on political action, real steps that people can take
- Scientists aren’t sure about a lot of things in the world, we don’t even know how clouds really work
-
We are always adding more information to the climate problem and constantly innovating!
Copyright 101
Mar 7, 2024 3:00 PM PST
Speaker: Mike Hiestand, Student Press Law Center
- What is copyright?
- Framed in Article 1, Section 8, Clause 8 of U.S. Constitution
- Tries to balance protecting creative efforts with sharing knowledge
- General rule: if you didn’t create the work and/or don’t own the copyright to it, you must get permission to use it → just giving credit is not enough
- Requirements for copyright
- Originality
- Some small level of creativity
- Fixed in some tangible medium
- Ideas and facts cannot be copyrighted!
- Also, federal works are not protected by copyright → should still be attributed, but you do not need permission to use
- Copyright also does not protect works whose copyright has expired
- Falls into the public domain once it is no longer copyrighted
- (Lots of conversation about this because Mickey Mouse was about to not be protected by copyright anymore in 1928.)
- Public domain: As of Jan. 1, 2024, copyrighted works from 1928 and before are in the U.S. public domain
- Works created on or after Jan. 1, 1978 have copyright protection for the life of the author plus 70 years
- No longer need formal registration for copyright
- Generally, the creator of the work owns the copyright, this includes student journalists. There are exceptions to this (i.e. if you are creating something on the job, that work belongs to the employer).
- Suggests putting together a copyright agreement - every staff member and contributor should sign one. Students retain copyright to their work. Student grants limited license to the publication to use their work
- Cannot just credit the source, you also need permission to use it!
- Digital watermarks are embedded within an image sometimes
- Auto generated copyright infringement notices
- DO NOT ignore
- Remove the infringing work
- Do your research
- Check statute of limitations
- Respond in writing
- Play the student media card
- Creative commons (CC) - alternative copyright licenses
- Make sure to look at the terms (especially the attribution)
- User retains right to photos and content
- Grants Instagram all the rights of an original owenr of the content
- Users can violate copyright law on their own account by positng material they do not own the copyright to
- Fair Use
- An exception to our general copyright policy
- Four factors of fair use
- Purpose/character of the use
- Nature of the copyrighted work
- How much of the original work is used
- The effect of the use on the potential market value of the original work
- Copyright law does not recognize any absolute “safe harbors” for use of text or audio
- Copyright v. parody
- Parody of original must be obvious
- Creativity counts
- Only use as much of the original work as necessary
- Minimal impact on market value of original
Words Matter: Making Your Content More Inclusive
Mar 7, 2024 3:00 PM PST
Speaker: Rachele Kanigel, San Francisco State University, Editor/writer/trainer for the Diversity Style Guide (kanigel@sfsu.edu)
- Inclusive content
- Aims to make everyone feel seen, heard, and represented, showcasing a wide variety of identities and beliefs
- Commitment to being accurate, up to data, and respectful — not about being “politically correct”
- Not just written content — applies to speakers, photographs, videos, etc.
- Be aware of changes to culture
- People and communities’ feelings will change about certain terms and identity descriptors; important to understand current
- Best gender-inclusive practices
- Always ask for pronouns
- Don’t use dead names even when talking about early life, or if it’s their legal name (*unless they expressly ask you to do that)
- Writing about race
- Consider whether race is relevant
- Ask people how they identify and what terms they use
- Be as specific as possible when describing identity if appropriate (if they provide that information)
- Latino/Latine/Latinx
- Latinx used primarily by younger people, most adults use Latino
- Latine easier for Spanish-speakers in the way it fits in the language
- Diversity Style Guide likes Latine, but it’s contentious/confusing/no clear consensus
- Disabilities
- National Center on Disability and Journalism has a guide (conforms to AP style) on disability
- Robert Maynard — fault lines
- Fault lines: rifts that affect how we interact with and view the world (age, race, gender, nationality, body size, etc.)
- Affect journalists’ ideas, sources, questions, quotes, images, etc.
- Ask:
- What fault lines does my work include? How can I mitigate it
- Mental health terminology
- Avoid language that belittles mental health conditions (I am so OCD!), consider the messages they convey
- Death/suicide
- “Commits suicide” implies a crime on their end → “died by suicide”
- Don’t include specifics about the mode of death, suicide notes, etc.
- When quoted individuals use insensitive language
- Leaving it in to leave a full picture of the person quoted (e.g. Trump)
- I.e. just don’t include the quote at all
- Case-by-case basis
- If someone just uses a “wrong” term, could put the correct wording in brackets
- Remove the quote
- Think of what role your org wants to play in the shaping of language and conversations
Inclusive Design: If it’s Not Accessible it’s Not Inclusive
Mar 7, 2024 3:00 PM PST
Speaker: Paige Connor, Pres and Founder of PKCX strategy, pres of Society for New Design foundation
- ADA does not enforce digital accessibility ‘guidelines’
- Color Contrast
- Difference in brightness and hue
- Use color contrast tools
- Don’t solely rely on color
- ALT Text
- Brief textual description added to an image in a digital document or webpage
- Caption describes the story, ALT describes the image
- Closed Captions
- Textual representations of the audio content in a video, synchronized with the timing of the video
- Kinetic captions
- Animated or dynamic (think the tik tok auto generated caption)
- Difficult to follow, more aesthetically interesting than user friendly
- Transcripts
- Recommends using Microsoft Word dictate feature
- Typography
- Affects readability and comprehension for all users
- Most accessible font → comic sans :)
Friday, March 8
An Introduction to the Deliberative Journalism Project
Mar 8, 2024 9:00 AM
Speaker: Jenny Fischer from Colorado State University, Co-Director of the NoCo Deliberative Journalism Project
- Goal of deliberative journalism is finding ways to encourage deliberation and conversation
- Give the community better information about shared values so we can have better conversations about tough issues - especially important in an election year!
- Deliberative journalism: a developing perspective that focuses on helping the community elevate their capacity to address their shared problems more collaboratively and effectively
- Draws insights from multiple fields and recognizes that simply providing quality information is not sufficient. Issues need to be engaged and framed in particular ways that work to avoid triggering the worst in human nature and can actually tap into the best, particularly our creativity
- Seeks to support the creative and collaborative efforts necessary for diverse, democratic communities to thrive
- Importance of opinion page: can give a fresh perspective on an experience or issue, fosters trust between newspapers and audience, a lot of stories start here
- The Spark
- The importance of local journalism to the quality of democracy
- Numerous challenges to the traditional journalism model
- Challenges and opportunities of social media
- Growing polarization and misinformation
- Growing distrust in our institutions
- Developing innovations in local journalism
- Explosion in the amount of data available
- CSU’s Center for Public Deliberation
- Organization runs meetings for organizations like the City of Fort Collins, CSU, Poudre School District
- CPD students serve as moderators and note-takers for groups at all meetings
- Goal of meetings is to eliminate polarization around tough issues, find middle group, and make sense of the noise
- Wicked problems inherently involve competing underlying values, paradoxes, and tradeoffs that cannot be resolved by science
- Water in Northern Colorado is a Wicked Problem
- Key Deliberative Responses
- Balancing (the long-term focus)
- Re-calibrating (short term corrections)
- Transcending (short term ideal)
- The Beginning of the DJP
- Key Committee included members of local media outlets, nonprofits, academic
- Four larger community meetings were held to discuss potential plans
- Seven Key Tasks of the DJP
- Ensuring broad voices are represented
- Improving the quality and accessibility of information on local issues
- Summarizing what we heard and reframing topics for quality engagement
- Engaging authentically (online and in person events)
- Serving as a catalyst for collaborative action
- Civic capacity building and community building
- Opinion page - but more
- Focus on public comment
- Integration with social media presence to prompt repsonses
- Recaps written to highlight reader comments - common themes, good questions, adding data nad responding to misconceptions
- Did not have to be a subscriber to respond! (Lower barriers to entry)
Audience Engagement 101
Mar 8, 2024 9:00 AM PST
Speaker: Kevin O’Keeffe, Assistant Director of Student Media at Loyola Marymount
- Unlike the print product, the audience doesn’t find you, you find the audience
- Goals:
- Draw audiences to content that lives primarily on your website
- Build more audience on the platform itself
- Big three social media networks
- Facebook:
- Only 22% of Facebook's users are between 18-24 – core audience won’t be here
- Audience is going to be parents and alums here
- X (formerly known as Twitter):
- 28% of X users are between 18-24
- Younger platform overall
- Best for specialty communities
- Journalists, sports fanatics, politicos, tech people
- Instagram:
- 31% of audience between 18-24
- Opinion does really well as does breaking news
- Tik Tok
- 37% of users are 18-24
- Tik Tok does not drive traffic to other platforms (users will simply watch your video, have the story and scroll away)
- However, this can be useful in getting people to know your brand better
- It is meaningful for people to know you and trust you as a news source
- Mailchimp/Newsletters
- Why is it useful:
- Draws audience to content which lives only on your website
- Create a direct-mailing list for reaching audience (think about it as DMing your audience)
- Why it is not so useful:
- Audiences can’t interact with each other
- Not audience engagement, more audience delivery
- Short shelf life
- Community Based Platforms
- Reddit and Discord
- They recommend editor’s note at the top of the comment section explaining you deleted comment and linking to the comment policy
- How much to post
- Instagram: 2-3 times per day ✓
- Twitter: throw everything up there and see what sticks
- Arts reviews don’t do well on the grid
- Instagram hashtags aren’t helpful, twitter is
- Whether to let staff members interact with comments on their personal accounts
- These individuals represent your organization as a whole, but it can be a good audience engagement tool as it puts a face to the person behind your content
- If you choose to let staff do this, set clear parameters
Newsroom Management For Students and Advisers
Mar 8, 2024 9:00 AM PST
Speaker: Olivia Palombo and Amy Carlyle, EICs at The Loyolan (Loyola Marymount); Tom Nelson, Adviser at The Loyolan
- Think about what things you’re doing right now that are stupid/illogical that you do just because it’s tradition
- Traditional journalism model: “this is what we think you need to know” top-down from journalists to community
- Public-powered mindset: “What do you not know that we could find out for you?” collaborative between journalists and the community
- The current state of journalism needs to be optimized for: the information age, listening, relevance, efficacy, depth, reader revenue, earned trust between the reader and audience
- “How do we get to where the students are, rather than trying to get them to our coverage/website”
- What do people want in a leader?
- Whether the newsroom leader could do the jobs they supervised
- Leaders with deep expertise in their field
- Works well in newsroom structure, because people work their way up to the leadership positions
- Good leadership behaviors to model
- Be honest about what you know/don’t know ⇒ “I’m not sure, but I can find out and get back to you”
- When you mess up:
- Apologize
- Determine what happened and what exactly went wrong
- Be part of the solution (and include everyone else that should be involved)
- Loyolan structure
- Similar to TMD: Exec board (big 4) → A1 (section MEs) → assistant editors → interns (staffers)
- Weekly check-ins between Exec board + A1
- Hiring
- 2-round interviews for every applicant
- Require some type of application sample for every application
- Conduct interviews and fill out a post-interview evaluation form
- Set bare-minimum standards
- Read your email and respond regularly and appropriately
- Be an active listener during staff and section meetings
- Respect your deadlines
- And be communicative when you know that you can’t make it
- Follow same hiring/leadership schedule as TMD, but the EIC transition happens in February
- Loyolan staff meetings → MDesk (?)
- Take attendance using QR
- Analytics → top story, video, most-liked post
- Announcements and learning moment
- Shoutouts/birthdays
- Retreat! Theirs is more educational
Freedom of Information Law
Mar 8, 2024 12:00 PM
Speaker: Mike Hiestand, Student Press Law Center
- Student Press Law Center
- Promotes, supports and defends the First Amendment and press freedom rights of high school and college journalism. Provides free legal help
- Mostly gets calls related to censorship
- Website: SPLC.org
- What are freedom of information laws?
- Your legal key to ensuring access to public records and meetings !
- Who is subject to FOI laws?
- Only public agencies or bodies
- Three types of FOI Law
- Open Records
- State open records laws
- Federal FOI
- Open Meetings
- State open meetings laws
- Federal government in the Sunshine Act
- “Pocket” FOI Laws
- Open Records Laws
- A public body must make its records available upon request unless the records are explicitly exempted by statute
- State Open Records Laws
- Used to obtain access to records of stae, county, or local government bodies
- Finding your law: www.rcfp.org/ogg
- Federal FOI law
- Records created, possess or controlled by a federal agency or maintained by an entity under government contract
- Do not apply to:
- Congress, federal courts, private corporates, federally funded state agencies
- FOI has its limitations
- Agencies aren’t required to:
- Conduct research, create a record that does not already exist, add explanatory materials to any records disclosed, or analyze data
- Requesting Records
- Verbal requests sometimes recognized by law
- Can set up an appointment in-person and physically request the document, build rapport, ask what specifically you should be asking for
- Submit written request where required or to establish “paper trail”
- Reasonably describe the record you are seeking
- Send to agency or person responsible for keeping the record
- Use www.splc.org/lettergenerator (state version)
- What happens next?
- Officials must either:
- Provide the records in a timely manner or
- Point to an exemption
- If you believe your request has been improperly denied
- Contact the recordkeeper and politely cite the law
- Administrative appeal sometimes available
- Judicial review
- Fines and/or attorney fees may be available
- Common exemptions
- Records involving “ongoing criminal investigation”
- Information that would jeopardize national security
- Police techniques
- Some personnel records like hiring, firing, disciplinary
- Education records kept by a school
- Family Education Right and Privacy Act (FERPA)
- Requires schools to provide a student (or sometimes parents) with a copy of his or her “education records” upon request
- Penalized schools that release a student’s “education records” without student (or sometimes parental) consent
- “Education Records”
- Includes most records that are directly related to a student and is maintained by the school in a central location
- Common examples: grades, test scores, some disciplinary records
- FERPA
- FERPA does not prohibit student journalists from publishing or disclosing information about other students; it only applies to school officials
- FERPA only restricts release of an “education record” that identifies a specific student. (Most statistical information should be available.)
- They can black out student names though, then provide that information.
- Be careful - if students are employed by the University, then they are sometimes entitled to reporting sexual assault to the University under Title IX
- Takeaway: don’t be employed by the University!
- Reports to explore
- Accreditation reports
- Academic performance reports
- Building inspection reports
- Fire safety inspection reports
- Campus crime reports
- Public health and safety inspections for dining halls
- Open Meetings Laws
- General law: a public body must provide notice of all gatherings and allow public attendance unless meeting is explicitly exempted by statute
- Attending public meetings
- Show up
- If you’re asked to leave, ask that the meeting minutes reflect your eviction —> make an appeal, talk to SPLC after
- Deliberation of certain things (eg personnel matters) can happen behind closed doors, but the vote has to be held publicly
- Common exemptions
- Discussion of personnel matters
- Discussion of individual students
- Matters involving highly personal information
- Discussion of ongoing or contemplated legal proceedings
- Meetings to discuss the acquisition of real estate
- Pocket FOI Laws
- Federal Clery Act (campus crime)
- Applies to all public and private institutions receiving federal financial assistance
- Annual campus security report
- Daily campus police log
- Timely alerts
- Noncompliance can result in fine of up to $13 million for each violation and potential loss of eligibility for federal aid
- Federal student “right to know” act
- Access to student graduation rates
- Access to athletic program information
- Access to accreditation reports
- IRS Form 990
- For expensive FOIAs
- Submit fee waivers
- Narrow the time frame for the request - instead of a year’s worth of emails look for a month versus a week
- Look into FOIA fee caps — each state has their own rules
- Reach out to SPLC for help
Podcasting for Student Media
Mar 8, 2024 10:00 AM PST
Speaker: Patti Piburn, journalism professor & KCPR advisor, Mustang Media Group
- Cute and intentional covers
- 93% of people who listen will finish all or most of the episode (podcast listeners are committed)
- Hook listeners in the beginning
- Important to trim, edit, get rid of space to keep people’s attention
- Podcasts that relay information are popular – people want to feel smarter!
- People want to feel a connection to the host
- Creating a local news podcast:
- 15-30 minutes
- Use existing news stories, talk to reporters to hear about their experience working on stories
- Promotes transparency, audience engagement, media literacy, practicing multimedia
- Sports podcast:
- Invite athletes and coaches (????)
- Your sports writers are experts in campus sports
- Rundown of top sports stories
- Center around interview
- Call to action: ask listener to visit website or listen to more episodes
- Incorporate video
- Putting faces to names to allow people to feel like they know the hosts
- Video helps to redirect people to the episode
- Production specifics
- Audio and video recorded separately
- Combine A/V in post-production
- They use adobe audition/ableton
- Promotion and Engagement
- Reels guidelines:
- 45 seconds-1 minute
- Always use same font
- They recommend animated captions for accessibility (this is not accessible though)
- Use logo
- In person events
- Set up table on campus with foot traffic, put a question on a table and let them come to you
- Builds brand awareness, consistent people and timing
- Motivation within the team
- People know when you’re not passionate about your podcast
- Their process
- Brainstorm → pre-show meeting → recording → editing → distribution
- Their podcasts
- For incoming students: how to do campus stuff, what to know, hyper specific
- News, sports, people of color round table, on the street discussion
Talking to Strangers
Mar 8, 2024 10:00 AM PST
Speaker: Dean Nelson, Founder and Director of Journalism Program at Point Loma Nazarene University (formerly NYT, Boston Globe, NPR)
- Intuitively we know that interviews matter, but why?
- In addition to facts and data, we need a human voice and unique perspective
- Interview necessities
- Experts and explainers to provide official accounts → these are typically the most careful sources (and often the most boring)
- Witnesses → describe the five senses of a story
- Stakeholders who are affected → these are often your most important sources
- People are often reluctant to be interviewed → time constraints, previous bad experience with reporters, general distrust of the press
- Distrust of the press is not a Trump-era phenomenon
- Government has consistently considered the press an “enemy of the people,” dating back to Nixon
- Overcoming this reluctance
- Emphasizing the need for that person’s unique perspective for the story
- “Readers will be better informed if they hear your take”
- “Your story matters”
- Acknowledging negative past experiences with the press, but explaining how things have changed/how you or your organization are different
- Play the student card!
- Authenticity matters
- Preparation
- Unless it’s for a breaking news story, you should know most of the answers to basic/informational questions already
- You are looking for a perspective, insight, anecdote, or unique way of expressing a point of view
- Preparation puts your source at ease and minimizes dishonesty/spin
- Plan your questions!!
- Put questions in order and leave tough questions until about two-thirds of the way through the interview to ask it
- Make it a conversation, not an interrogation
- Check your ego → you’re not trying to win an argument, you’re trying to get a perspective
- Ask an easy question or two at the end
- Be ready to improvise → actively listening and following up
- Tips for effective interviewing
- Where it happens matters (most important for in-person interviews)
- Silence is part of any interview
- Impressions and body language matter → how you dress, taking notes when appropriate, etc.
- Keep it conversational, but challenge incorrect or obnoxious statements
- Take your time writing notes
- And always take notes! Even when recording
- Take more notes immediately after
- Always ask if there is anything else they want to add, who else you can contact about this, and if you can contact them with more questions
How to Be a Strong Newsroom Leader
Mar 8, 2024 12:30 PM PST
Speaker: Rick Green, Lexington Herald
- “When you bruise, it’s because you’re moving forward”
- Tips to being a good newsroom leader:
- Communication
- Written communication
- Authenticity
- “Theatre of leadership”; you’re always on display
- Trust your staff and delegate
- Acknowledge your shortcomings and work on them (invest in yourself!)
Localizing the Presidential Election
Mar 8, 2024 12:30 PM PST
Speaker: Jere Hester, CUNY J-School
- Main goal for election coverage: serving your audience’s interests and needs
- Identifying stories to tackle
- Planning how to tackle them
- How to bring attention to them
- College journalism is going to be particularly important for the 2024 election → college student voter turnout rose in 2020 and 2022
- The issues we care about as college students are often the issues a big piece of the electorate cares about too (climate change, abortion access, student loans)
- Campuses are at the center of issues that are likely to play a big role in the election
- How does your newsroom decide what to cover?
- Start by listening
- Meeting your audience where they “live” both online and in real life
- Ask focused, but open-ended questions
- What issues do they want to know more about?
- What information do they need to make decisions?
- Localized coverage happens in two ways:
- Taking a big story and highlighting how it impacts your community
- Reaction is a part of the story, but not the whole story
- Talk to local experts and decision-makers
- Get localized data → especially relevant when it comes to things like climate, health care and budget
- Never assume that everyone knows the bigger story
- Don’t want to repeat other/larger stories, but context is necessary
- Serve both people who already know about an issue/event, and bring new people into the conversation
- Writing stories/highlighting issues that are not talked about in national outlets
- Example: 2021 NYC Mayoral Elections
- Sent out a form where people could share what questions they had for mayoral candidates
- Created an election hub with explainer stories, past coverage, etc.
- Sent a questionnaire to all candidates → “Meet your Mayor”
- When a candidate didn’t answer a question, they included information about their stance found in public records
- Matched people to candidates who most aligned with their views
- Get in candidates’ faces!
Redefining Community in the Practice of Journalism
Mar 8, 2024 1:30 PM PST
Speaker: Estella Porras, Cal-State, Monterey Bay
- What is community?
- Word means different things to different people
- Imagined communities
- Communities of stories and conversations that create a sense of who we are and who we identify with
- Benedict Anderson’s discussion of nation as an imagined community
- See others as fellow citizens even though we don’t know them
- Colombia “imagined” by the news coverage of road cycling
- What does the notion of imagined communities mean for journalists?
- Makes us think about who is included in our stories, whose voices are included, and where are our sources from?
- Mapping and observing our sources is important - observe in person and physically see what the problems of a community might be
- Listing: what are the top ten places to nap or to study (people want to know this, asking people about these places can give us a mental map of our campus)
- Community as a Public Sphere
- Origin democracy in ancient Greece, people had conversations about what is “public”
- People that were having these discussions were called “citizens”, people who were free (no women or enslaved people)
- Deliberation: decisions made based on arguments
- Habermas studied the public sphere: sites citizens had conversations about the collective living
- Newspapers created an informed public opinion
- Is our community a public sphere?
- Recipe for democracy: public sphere (spaces of citizens conversing) + information _ rational arguments + deliberation = democracy
- How can our journalism practice promote healthy public spheres?
- Invite conversation on public matters (ex. Unpacking an issue, a bill, a policy)
- Examples: cliffhanger stories. Expand the conversation on social media or directly with the experts
- Citizen’s driven agenda
- What are the things my readers want most from school/their city?
- Indigenous views: bien vivir (living well)
- Have a connection with the land and the community
- New paradigm of social and ecological commons
- Rooted in cosmovision (one-with-others, including nature)
- No separation - interconnectedness
- Redefining community and journalism
- Imagined communities: include stories that make people and spaces visible
- Public sphere: citizen’s driven agenda
- Buen Vivir: Interconnectedness “I am with others.”
Traditional Art in the Digital Age
Mar 8, 2024 1:30 PM PST
Speaker: Art director of Word Magazine (UC Santa Barbara)
- Think about it early
- Thumbnail
- If you’re working traditionally, you have to have a clear plan because it's much more difficult to make major changes once things are on paper
- Plan and Prep
- Dimensions (include bleed margins)
- Use VueScan for high quality scans
- In color
- Size: Scan at correct size (for dimensions plus bleed lines)
- Scan/preview resolution
- 300 dpi
- Save as a TIFF (not JPEG or PNG)
- They’re huge files
- PROCREATE!!!!
- Use the clone feature (adjustments → clone) to mock the same texture of a scanned paper
Excellence and Mental Health Can Coexist: Discussion for Editors
Mar 8, 2024 1:30 PM PST
Speaker: Mia Hennen, The Sunflower (Wichita State University)
- As EIC → delegate! Ask 3 before me!
- Communicate separately about work w friends
- Editor + staff bonding, don’t let people get siloed / don’t silo yourself off
- Making events for the whole staff to do (be conscious of cost)
- Create spaces for staff to bond and make friendships (be people, too) outside of the workplace
- Compliment your staff
- Written + other content
- Let people have bad days/weeks
- Be understanding of people’s circumstances/mental health/personal life
- Be able to accommodate people’s absence, be flexible about deadlines (within reason), allow them to take time off
- Setting clear expectations about what conduct is okay/not okay in the newsroom
- Clear expectations about gossip, reporting information, having conversations with editors and leadership, etc.
- Keep reminding staff about expectations (midpoint reminder)
- Looking after your own mental health
- Delegating responsibilities
- Create work and life (school, etc.) boundaries
- Not necessary to take on every single problem right in the moment (it’s okay to tell someone we can meet at a different time)
- Taking physical breaks from the newsroom
Getting Pushback From Administration? Push Back.
Mar 8, 2024 2:30 PM
Speakers: Chuck Clark (check.clark@wku.edu), Adviser at College Heights Herald (Western Kentucky University) and Amy DeVault (amy.devault@wichita.edu), Adviser at The Sunflower (Wichita State University)
- Just because they won’t talk to you doesn’t mean you shouldn’t cover it → cover it, and say they wouldn’t talk to you
- Can potentially explain why The Daily wanted to speak to the source that denied a comment/interview
- If not getting a complete interview, can potentially do another story on administration (or another source of authority) refusing to talk to the media (example: running a story as a Q&A when the University President is refusing to answer questions and gives a 5 minute interview)
- Charging excessive FOIA fees
- Put numbers into print!
- EG: Wichita State University quoted The Sunflower $1,500 for a FOIA request for financial records on a campus housing development
- Check state law! → In Kentucky, public agencies cannot charge more than 10 cents/page
- Cannot charge someone for the time of the staffer sending the documents/compiling them!
- Three reasons why a public meeting can be closed in Kentucky (check state documents)
- Specific litigation of a crime
- Employee affairs
- Real estate deliberations
- Threats to funding
Covering Protests
Mar 8, 2024 2:30 PM
Speakers: Lindsie Rank, SPFI, and two photojournalists from the San Diego Union Tribune
- When covering protests, you should have:
- Some type of covering over your eyes
- (pulls out a bulletproof vest)
- (pulls out extremely sophisticated mask to protect against being gassed)
- Being approached by various parties (police, protesters, etc.)
- Diffuse the situation; never escalate, antagonize, or argue
- Take notes, photos, be cordial, polite, etc. ⇒ decide what makes it into your story later
- Sometimes, wearing your press pass (or PPE) makes you a target
- Evaluate the situation you’re in and decide accordingly
- Strength in numbers — having a buddy with you at these protests can help, keep an eye out for you
- In public, people have no reasonable expectation of privacy
- If people are protesting, you legally can take photos, videos of people (there is no reason to redact, blur photos or ask for permission other than ethical reasons)
- Think about the ethical considerations of publishing faces/names/etc. of protesters (convo among editors)
- If arrested:
- Make clear that you’re press
- Write phone #s on your arm you might need to call in sharpie
- Do not unlock your phone
- Do not consent to search
- Know Miranda rights and ask for your lawyer
- Don’t say anything else!!
- Don’t say “I want a lawyer, dawg” (?!)
Breaking the Bounds
Mar 8, 2024 3:30 PM PST
Speakers: Mishal Charania and Carly Nicholas, both from the Michiganensian!!
- Spreads should look different
- Might be boring if you see the same thing over and over again
- The yearbook should encapsulate the distinctive experiences, memories, and character of the academic year
- Marrying the copy and photo using impactful design
- Michiganensian is thematic without using a theme
- The template lifestyle can limit creativity and individuality
- Freestyle lifestyle is better!
- Might be more difficult to highlight special moments when a template is more rigid
- Design for the spread, don’t design for the book
- Lines are used to represent connections between students and between both students and the university
- These lines are found all over the look, on the bound of the book and on the page letters
- Might look like a small element but is something that ties the book together
- Everything done is still purposeful, not having a strict theme does not mean do whatever you want to do
- Some templates, but they don’t guide people toward certain things (includes shapes and text)
- These encourage designers to think about shapes in different ways
- Use shapes intentionally
- Two main categories that classify Michiganensian design: simplistic and minimal, and bold and fresh
- Building text around photos is a strategy
- Keep in mind that designers don’t know what photos they will get (they don’t request them), work with what they have
- Every spread doesn’t need more than one color, just depends on the photo
- Can be subtle about other design elements
- Utilize different fonts, especially in headlines
- Together, these spreads make up our yearbook but makes the reader want to do to each page and see how each story is represented uniquely
- Makes you want to keep turning the page
- Can’t use maize and blue on sports spreads
- Colors are chosen and connected in some way
- Interesting to play off colors of opponents in football and sporting spreads
- Do not use theme elements that takes away from the spread
- Goal of templates is to be cohesive and feel uniform, but if you’re not taking risks you’re missing out on opportunities to represent what is important to the student body!
Covering Sexual Assault, Legally
Mar 8, 2024 3:30 PM PST
Speaker: Anne Marie Tamburro, SPFI
- Digging up records
- Under the Clery Act, you can get:
- Annual reports → how many sexual assaults are happening on your campus annually?
- Not very specific, but can provide insight into trends and general culture at your institution
- Daily crime log → what happened yesterday?
- Within 60 days, must be available for inspection
- Prior to 60 days, must be available within two days
- Under state public records laws, you can usually get law enforcement records (police reports, police communications) and you should be able to get names, violations, and sanctions of those found where the discipline was for a crime of violence or non-forcible sexual offense
- Under FERPA, you can usually get student records if you have a source who is willing to consent to disclosure of their records
- People often think of FERPA as a way to protect student information, but it can also be a way to gain information → it allows students to gain access to their own records
- FERPA has a carve-out that allows records to be released with information redacted → if an institution denies a request on the basis of FERPA, you can ask for all of the information except for the student information
- EG: If you are talking to a student who is a survivor of sexual assault for a story, they can request records on how their case was handled from the university
- Protecting your sources
- Most states have some version of a shield law that protects you from having to disclose confidential source information to state officials
- Some states have them, but they don’t apply to student journalists
- They may apply both to the identity of sources and to any pre-publication work product
- Shield laws usually provide a qualified privilege
- This means the privilege to keep information confidential isn’t absolute → there are exceptions, usually if:
- Information is otherwise unavailable
- Compelling and overriding interest
- Info is clearly relevant to an important issue in the case
- Mandatory reporting rules → who on your staff is a mandated reporter? **RAs**
- More than two-thirds of universities choose to designate all employees as mandatory reporters
- Avoiding legal liability
- Student journalists who follow standard journalistic norms and ethics are unlikely to get sued, and even less likely to lose a lawsuit
- Do everything a reasonable journalist would, and nothing a reasonable journalist wouldn’t
- Main legal problem → defamation
- Standards for defamation:
- Must be false and not opinion
- If the subject is a public figure or official, they must show that you knew or had reason to know the information was false
- If the subject is a private individual, they must show you were negligent (you did not do what a reasonable journalist would do in that situation)
Good Designers Copy. Great Designers Steal.
Mar 8, 2024 3:30 PM
Speaker: Kevin Fullerton, Creative Director of Springboard Creative
- Taking boring images and using a familiar visual language to tell stories through the graphic
- EG: mob boss story where different boxes showed how each man in the group photo died
- Layout should be about the story, not the design.
- The design should tell the story, maybe better than the story could be told otherwise
- Never do something simply because it ‘looks cool’
- Should be a communicator first and an artist second
- Reverse copy (white text on color)
- Especially on newsprint, make sure that the font size is higher and the leading is turned up. By the time the ink spreads, it’ll look similar to the rest of the text
Saturday, March 9
Writing About Trauma in Nonfiction
Mar 9, 2024 9:00 AM PST
Speaker: Courtenay Stallings, Asst. Director of Pepperdine Graphic Media (courtenay.stallings@pepperdine.edu)
- Responding to someone sharing a traumatic experience in an interview
- Acknowledging and listening, but not acting as a therapist
- Preventing retraumatization → “breaking the rules of journalism”
- Possibly provide questions ahead of time
- When should you write about your own trauma?
- Ask yourself what your purpose is in writing your own story
- Be prepared for what emotions might arise, consult a mental health professional before if possible
- Writing about your trauma for public consumption has challenges → backlash, friends and family may read it
- There is no pressure to share everything
- How do you tell stories about others’ trauma
- Gain trust and set boundaries before the interview occurs
- Don’t begin the interview by discussing trauma → learn more about who they are as a person beyond what happened to them
- Do not hesitate to reach out to the person for clarity and to ensure accuracy in telling their story
- Processing vicarious trauma
- You do not have to do it alone → lean on editors, newsroom for support
- If needed, take a step back from what you’re working on
- What does it mean to write about trauma ethically?
- Minimizing harm
- When interviewing a survivor, proceed with caution and lead with compassion
- Language used → survivor vs. victim
- Ask the person you are interviewing what they prefer
- Trauma-informed journalism + resources
- Building trust with both the source and your audience
- “The Trauma Beat” by Tamara Cherry
- Looks at how the traditional journalism system is set up to fail trauma survivors and journalists
- Talks about solutions, resources, etc.
- Poynter: 15-minute Journalism and Trauma Self-Directed free course
- Dart Center for Journalism & Trauma
Breaking News Coverage and Tight Deadlines
Mar 9, 2024 9:00 AM PST
- Breakout session with Alejandro Tamayo, The San Diego Union Tribune
- He is a visual/photojournalist and has worked in San Diego as a photojournalist for 12 years
- Focuses on border issues - he now lives in Tijuana (2,000 homicides each year)
- Covers issues on both sides of the border
- Breaking news: every situation is different, especially different in Mexico and the U.S.
- In the U.S., the police are usually already there - not true in Mexico (journalists have more access but also more risk)
- Threats to journalists in Mexico when images are taken of something you should not have taken a picture of
- Deadlines in our world
- Go and cover the scene/environment, then immediately get it back to the paper
- Send a picture to the editors right when he arrives to the situation
- Depending on radio calls/number of reporters are there depends on how much coverage you will do on the event
- Don’t bring too many cameras - just one - you may have to walk
- Work out of your car, coffee shops, whatever is close by!
- Bring your laptop and cell phone (hot spot connection from iPhone is important)
- Focus on one assignment at a time - don’t procrastinate on getting your stuff back to the editors
- Getting more than one assignment in a day can be stressful, work on one at a time
- His experience:
- Went to Pulse nightclub.
- Here he worked with other reporters from Orlando, who worked much differently than his organization in San Diego.
- There was lots of coverage from this: about the survivors, the families impacted, much more.
- Photojournalism tips
- Get your video and photos to editors ASAP - in 24/7 news cycle it quickly becomes irrelevant
- Try to plan shots if you can
- Understand what you need in the shortest amount of minutes or seconds in an interview (for video)
- Think about: who, what, when, where, why because this is what breaking news is - getting information to the public
- In some assignments, you may want to go back and go deeper into the breaking news-related issues
- Balance seeing the difficult parts of breaking news stories with fun stories
- Disconnect when you’re not working, spend time with family or friends
Reporting on Trans Issues
Mar 9, 2024 9:00 AM
Speaker: Irene Milanez (they/them) and Alexia Frederkson (she/they), San Jose State University, Spartan Daily
- Ask your subject what pronouns they would like to appear in the story
- It might be appropriate to make a note at the beginning of your story stating that a subject uses multiple pronouns to avoid confusion
- Can introduce a source as ‘x person, who uses they/them pronouns’
- There is almost never a reason to deadname a trans person in a story
- If source deadnames a person, don’t use the quote verbatim
- Avoid:
- Term “preferred pronouns”
- References to “assigned female/male at birth”, use instead “was raised as girl/boy”. Not all trans people are comfortable being referred to the by their sex
- Assigned sex at birth is politicized. Feels unchanging
- Detransitioner
- This is anti-trans language
- Detransition is appropriate as a verb, not as an adjective
- Terms gender ideology, transgenderism, trans ideology/agenda are anti trans
- Transgendered, use instead Transgender
- ‘Trans-male’ or ‘trans-female’
- Confusing and used multiple ways
- Saying someone is ‘allegedly’ or ‘accused of’ being Trans
- Trans children
- Prioritize speaking to child and parents
- Think about consequences of publishing information about trans children
- Death of trans people
- Don’t assume death was related to identity
- Anti-trans politics
- Don’t take politicians at their word on what the bill is, ask someone to offer broader context
- Crime
- Seek sources beyond law enforcement
- Law enforcement might provide records displaying incorrect names or pronouns
- Incarcerated trans people
- If your source is incarcerated, remember legal and chosen names might not match
- Consider granting anonymity
- Health Care
- Gender-neutral terms in health coverage:
- Avoid equating gender and anatomy instead, consider who is affected
- “People with ovaries” or “people with prostates”
- If cis women, for example, are primarily affected “women and other patients” might be appropriate
- Be careful about how you talk about transition
- Many people, trans children specifically, might be transitioned, but are not getting gender affirming health care. Contextualize and differentiate this appropriately
- Detransitioning
- People might detransition for myriad reasons. Don’t assume it’s because they ‘are no longer trans’ or made a mistake
- Clarify with your source how they would categorize this
- Gender affirming care
- Be specific about what care it is
- Gender affirming care is not specific to trans people
- Avoid “male hormones” or “female hormones” – be specific
- Sports
- Don’t assume regulation of trans athletes is based in scientific fact
- Testosterone regulations are constantly changing
- Trans men and non-binary athletes are largely ignored in reporting on trans athletes
- Drag
- Character based performance art
- ‘Drag performer’ instead of ‘Drag King’ or ‘Drag Queen’
- Some might use certain pronouns when in character – clarify names and pronouns they want printed
- Generally use stage name over legal name
- Describing people
- Avoid describing height, pitch of voice, etc. which might imply that they are not really the gender they identify with or could unintentionally out someone
- Don’t identify characteristics as masculine, feminine or androgynous
- Sex work
- Use ‘sex worker’ over ‘prostitute’ or ‘escort’
- Some sex workers might use names other than their legal name, clarify what they’d like to have used
- Use the Trans Journalists Association's style guide + glossary of terms
Cover the capitol from your campus
Mar 9, 2024 10:00 AM PST
Speaker: Jennifer Burger and Matthew Reagan, CalMatters
- State and federal policy is community policy, University policy is higher education policy
- CalMatters: based in Sacramento and is a nonprofit reporting on higher education
- Public institutions have policy on where money comes from, how it is spent, and public access to information
- For public and private institutions, government policies cover everything from anti-harassment and discrimination rules to financial aid, employment, admissions and research grants
- How to build a higher education beat
- Statehouse reporting
- College system governance
- Federal government
- State and national data
- Education news sources
- Who makes the laws?
- All states except Nebraska have bicameral legislatures
- Each has a committee on higher education, which holds hearings and develops policies that could turn into bills then laws
- Legislative staff produce reports that are full of data and analysis on how higher education policy is functioning or could impact the state
- Legislative Analyst’s Office
- System reports
- Campus reports
- Example: look at difference between number of students enrolled and existing campus housing inventory (they also often have the number of students on campus housing waiting lists)
- Politico’s 2021 version of “I’m Just a Bill”
- Utilize Digital Democracy (this is in California but they might have a version in Michigan) that transcribes all state legislature meetings and gives information on positions of each state representative
- Legislatures need to disclose all gifts!! May be an interesting story to look into
- U.S. Department of Education
- Administers federal programs that impact all colleges and universities in the nation
- Examples
- Financial Aid
- Student loans
- Anti-discrimination (Title IX)
- The Dream Act
- Their advice: get wine (if you’re 21!!!) and sit down with iPads and look through state data for hours and hours….
- Look into what other news organizations are reporting on (state and national news, also student publications)
- National news: inside higher ed, the chronicle of education, open campus, etc.
How to Brand Across Multiple Platforms
Mar 9, 2024 10:00 AM
Speaker: Tami Bongiorni, Digital Media Supervisor at Brokaw
- Tag yourself in your post
- Multiple brands should interact with one another
Make Your Policy Manual a Living Document
Mar 9, 2024 10:00 AM
Speaker: Chuck Clark, College Heights Herald, Western Kentucky University
- What is a policy manual?
- Delegates responsibilities
- Includes mission statement
- Sets clear expectations for conduct and content
- ACP Model Code of Ethics can be helpful to look at
- It should be a living document
- All WKU staff sign their policy manual when they join staff
- Case study: Copyright Policy
- Any content produced for the paper belongs to Student Pubs, they hold copyright for any other use by student publication
- Students hold copyright for any other use outside of student publications (use for portfolio, can sell to other people)
- Have a lawyer that went through and approved the policy
- All staff must electronically sign the policy (copyright policy and manual) before joining
- Case study: Plagiarism and fabrication
- Plagiarism incident at WKU → plagiarism and fabrication policy put into the manual
- Case study: Suicide and other sensitive stories
- Suicide on campus → paper publicly reported the event in great detail (as per the police report)
- AP Stylebook says provide minimal details
- Bad judgment call, not a factual error
- Created a policy on reporting suicides
- Directly pulled language from the AP into their own policy (vs. saying “we adhere to AP style”)
- “Editors are strongly encouraged to seek advice from professionals/adviser when reporting on this issue”
- AI
- Possibly creating a policy
- Think about the role it plays that’s not writing articles (grammar check, editing, etc.)
- Disclosing when it is used for articles (at least for now)
- Other school has random AI detectors they run on articles (INSANE !!!!!)
- Literal cop behavior like calm down
DEI tools for your newsroom
Mar 9, 2024 11:00 AM PST
Ideas: Madison Luc, Joe Heinemann, and Marley Penagos, Pepperdine University
- Why?
- PGM is not just one homogenous body
- Our aim is to highlight, elevate and learn from all the voices that amke up Pepperdine and Malibu
- The DEI tracker helps us identify areas of growth and areas we need growth
- Need to ensure we don’t get the same voices every time!
- Sometimes, we need to go back to a source time and time again - like the University President
- Don’t just ask people you know or club leaders, don’t reuse sources
- DEI Tracker
- Use Google Form
- Make sure we are understanding that we are hearing from different perspectives (think: are we including people with different ability levels, international backgrounds, etc.)
- Form includes: title, publishing data, asking if the story is specifically about BIPOC, POC, LGBTQIA+, people with disabilities, or other marginalized groups (ask the reporter!)
- Ask which section the story belongs to, asks how many sources are in the story
- Art in the DEI tracker
- Ask if a story contains art
- Does the art include illustrations of people, list the perceived or intended racial/ethnic identity, gender identity, and sexuality of the people
- People will usually draw people that look like themselves unconsciously
- Ask if a story contains photos
- Ask if the photos include people, if so, then list the perceived racial/ethnic identity, gender identity, and sexuality of the people
- Does the story contain an infographic, what information is it highlighting?
- Unique sources
- For all of 2023, 94% of stories tracked contained unique sources
- Pepperdine’s most used sources in the tracker were head of athletics programs
- Can see how many sources are in each story
- Remind people to fill it out when you can, like adding it to the payroll form
- Don’t impose a quota on DEI stories - we are not just checking a box
- Would this be audience facing (i.e. the results of our reporting)?
- Planning on doing a story on the graphics, reporting on ourselves
- Tracking our own newsroom:
- Pepperdine looks at religion, ethnicity, if they are a transfer student, gender
- Based on student data system
- Pre-dominantly white newsroom at Pepperdine
- Do a “by the numbers” story
- Students can connect to other students, different than major news organizations, coming at them from the human-to-human connection
- How to handle working with organizations that have mistrust toward the media?
- News talks at Pepperdine - an event where senior leaders go into each chapter meeting for fraternity or sororities on campus, can be applicable to other organizations
- Be as transparent as possible
- Explain why you are recording, saying “this is your opportunity to share your thoughts, what happened, in your own words”
- Suggestion: spend more time with them outside of the protest, get coffee with people, invite them to write an Op-Ed, being seen as someone who is helping them use their voice
- Have the EPE give them advice on how to write Op-Ed
Covering campus death
Mar 9, 2024 12:00 PM PST
- Breakout session with Angel Wood and Rhiannon Bent from Sun News, Utah Tech University
- Potential stories:
- Accidents, crime, cancer/illness, unknown/unexpected/suicide
- Potential challenges:
- Finding out
- Every life matters
- Stigma of suicide
- Pros: awareness, visibility
- Cons: fears over furthering the crisis
- Sources
- Roadblocks with sources
- Be persistent
- Ask for more context to the story
- Interviewing sensitively
- Give them a reason to share their story
- Making sure that this does not happen to anyone else for example
- Think about your approach
- Write a letter - reaching out to a family member or friend or roommate over social media to introduce yourself and tell more about the story you want to share. Say why participation of this person in the story is in everyone’s best interest.
- Show respect
- “I am so sorry for your loss.”
- Acknowledge it’s difficulty
- Be patient
- Don’t over-emphasize
- Helpful resource: poynter.org
- Be cautious about approach, maybe breaking news element of talking to the family is not in the best interest for those involved
- Language
- Death terminology
- AP style- died
- Suicide
- “Died by suicide”
- Avoid term “committing suicide”
- AP generally doesn’t cover suicides
- Do research beforehand
- Include elements like name, funeral home location
- Uncomfortable situation but i’s our jobs
- Video coverage
- Things to consider
- B-roll shot
- Audio
- Images
- Interviews
- Things you can do
- Content warning
- Blur
- Use different shots
- A follow up
- Visuals
- Photography tells a story in itself
- Photos back up facts
- Asking for personal photos- be sensitive, kind, thoughtful
- Social media photo?
- Be aware of your audience and the culture surrounding
- Ask the family if you can use their social media posts!
- Be aware of your audience and the culture surrounding
- Student athlete dealth coverage
- Remembrance
- Memorial tributes
- Support for teammates
- Community engagement
- Legacy initiatives
- Crisis management
- University releases statements
- A statement including quotes from coaches and fellow athletes speak to the person being remembered
- Provided resources for students regarding support and counseling
- Go on social media and see who was related or friends with the deceased
- Don’t report on rumors or speculations, we research and investigate them, don’t just report on what you hear
- Learn from others- look at other student publications